PIONEER PD-D9 vs PD-D6

MJ28.03.2008

Digital sources

Pioneeru has made it again with both the players. Especially the PD-D9 can challenge successfully any player in the one-thousand-euro price level. I am convinced that the aspirations of the PD-D9 may in fact be even higher - not a lot of CD players sound like this. The only thing I regret is that none of the Pioneers uses the excellent Stable Platter transport that was Pioneer's specialty in 90's.

Function and form

95%
Ease of use
43%
Sound
88%
Appearance

The front panels of the new CD players are divided in two halves by a curved transition. There are Sony CD transports on the right and monochromatic displays on the left. All control has to done through a remote controller as the fascias offer just very basic function (Open/Close, Play/Stop). The chassis are all aluminum, the connectivity is usual: RCA, XLR, Toslink, coaxial. The PD-D6 is 50% less costy than its bigger brother.

Bass management

Weight
77
Slam
57
Articulation
57

There are 192kHz/24bit Burr-Brown D/A converters in the heart of the PD-D6, plus the Pioneer's Legato Link conversion circuits. In early 90's Pioneer analyzed the noise of vinyl records to find out that it contains bits of information. They added the noise to the useful signal so that it extended the audible audioband. There are several versions of the LLC - the PD-D6 and the PD-D9 feature the Legato Pro. The circuit is defeatable as well as it is possible to switch off the display and digital outputs by pressing Pure Audio button.

The Pioneer PD-D9 is built from aluminum and unlike the PD-D6 it is of sandwich cnostruction to suppress resonances in the chassis. It is also heavier (10kg). The Burr-Brown DACs were replaced by two parallel Wolfson 192kHz/24bit chips. Other than that it shares the other features with the PD-D9.

Clarity & delicacy

Detail
58
Air
54
Transparency
50

I could not believe my ears when I auditioned the PD-D6 for the first time. What? A 500 EUR CD player? And it is that good? The excellent Joe Cocker's You Can Leave Your Hat On in its acoustic version was just amazing. The sound was highly resolved, had enough textures and great soundstage. The guitars had nice round body to their sound and were clean and dynamic as was the choir.

When I switched from the PD-D6-J to the PD-D9 I observed even better detail, dynamics and especially more of ambient clues. The soundstage became better layered, the noises in the background became more apparent, the music was more "there" and images snapped into better focus. Pink Floyd sounded like Pink Floyd irrespective of how high I turned up volume. The SACD mode brought another improvement, especially in tonal smoothness and textures.

Tonal accuracy

Timbre
48
Dynamics
50
Temporal resolution
48

Both the Pioneers have a lot in common, the way they handle the detail being one of the most prominent feature. I believe that this sophisticated subtlety is due to the Legato Link in signal's way. It was interesting to compare the Pioneers with Denon's DCD-1500AE entry-level player. The either of the Pioneers was richer, more accurate tonally and more emotionally involving, as well as it went deeper and made music more solid. The Denon was quite sterile in comparison. The other player that was used, Cambridge Audio's Azur 840C sounded veiled, too forward and less sophisticated with audibly flatter dynamics.

Spatial resolution

Holography
68
Soundstage width
68
Soundstage depth
68

When I experimented with enabling and disabling the Legato Link circuits I did not arrive to any conclusion, though my reference recordings sounded better with the LLC activated. Depending on a recording I preferred one mode or another. In the end I wished this option was not included as it took my attention away from music and I was endlessly pushing the button in the quest for "the right" sound.

Price as reviewed:26 000,- Kč

Recommended resellers

Basys CS, Praha tel. +420 234 706 700

Associated components

  • Sources: Denon DCD-1500AE, Cambridge Audio Azur 840C
  • Amplifiers: Audio Research SP17 / SD135
  • Interconnects and speaker cables: Nordost Valhalla
  • Loudspeakers: Usher BE-10 Dancer
  • Power conditioning: Accuphase PS-510

Gallery

ACCUPHASE DG-58

The Accuphase DG-58 is a 4th generation 'voicing equalizer' of Japanese manufacturer. The device won me over with its impeccable finish, top notch operation and a friendly user interface. It comes in traditional satin gold with high ...

Recommended resellers

Nisel SK, Bratislava, tel. +421 905 203 078

Sound
96%

ACCUPHASE DP-720 SACD

Accuphase engineers further expanded on the features that had made their   DP-900/DC-900 transport/DAC combo so phenomenal - the result is the one-box DP-720. This player is built with almost fanatical attention to detail. The ...

Recommended resellers

Nisel SK, Bratislava, tel. +421 905 203 078

Sound
94%

AUDIOLAB 8300CD

The 8300CD is a preamplifier, a CD player and a DAC (ESS Sabre), all in one neat package. Audiolab offers 8300MB monoblocks that are half-width of the 8300CD so the two monos and one source component create a compact high end system. ...

Recommended resellers

Horn Distribution, Praha, +420 272 656 485

Sound
44%

AUDIOQUEST Dragonfly Red

The original USB DAC of Audioquest happened to be a small revolution back in 2012. Four years later there are already more newborn dragonflies – v1.2, Black and Red. This review is focusing on the latest Red version that has ...

Recommended resellers

AQ s.r.o., Červenka, tel. +420 585 342 232

Sound
48%

AYON CD-07s

Smooth liquidity is another typical element of the Ayon sound. The sound is analog-like, viscose, fluid, flowing, smooth. You may as well discard all these adjectives and replace them with the single formulation: the Ayon is a ...

Recommended resellers

Nisel SK, Bratislava, tel. +421 905 203 078

Sound
63%

AYON CD-35 Signature SACD

The CD-35 is one of the most versatile digital players available. In its “Signature” version (the one we used throughout this review) it replaces a CD and an SACD player, a highly capable DAC, and an excellent preamplifier. Thus the ...

Recommended resellers

Nisel SK, Bratislava, tel. +421 905 203 078

Sound
91%

AYON CD-5s

The Ayon CD-5s is not a revolutionary different CD player from Ayon CD-07s which we used as a benchmark. However, its topology and component base are fine tuned to perfection plus a bit of high-end attractivity is thrown into the ...

Recommended resellers

Nisel SK, Bratislava, tel. +421 905 203 078

Sound
77%
Back to category